You are here

Головна » Scientific Journal of Veterinary Medicine 1'2025

Detection of granular salmon fish caviar falsi f ication by starch content

Grainy caviar salmon is one of the most valuable, nutritious and beneficial food products for human health, as it contains high-quality proteins, fats, polyunsaturated fatty acids, vitamins, micro- and macro elements. Currently, new varieties of caviar products are appearing on the Ukrainian market. Therefore, the reasons for the production and sale of fish caviar that does not meet regulatory requirements are, on the one hand, the imperfection of state oversight during the production and distribution, and on the other hand, the desire of unscrupulous manufacturers to reduce production costs in order to obtain excess profits by replacing one type of caviar with another, adding im itation caviar to natural caviar, replacing natural cav iar with artificial caviar, etc. The purpose of the study is to develop a method for detecting impurities of artificial granular caviar in natural granular salmon caviar based on starch content. The materials for the study were samples of natural granular caviar of salmon (n=16): chum salmon (n=4), pink salmon (n=4), trout (n=4), sockeye salm on (n=4), purchased from retail outlets in Kharkiv. Also, samples of imitation caviar (n=10) were studied, which were the objects of research in the forensic examination of food products conducted at National Scientific Center «Ноn. Prof. М.S. Bokarius Forensic Science Institute» of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine. The labeling of the imitation caviar indicated that it was natural caviar, but it did not meet the regulatory requirements for natural caviar. To detect the presence of artificial granular caviar in natural granular salmonid caviar, microscope slides containing homogenized caviar grains were stained with Lugol’s solution. The work substantiates and develops a method for detecting artificial granular caviar impurities in natural granular salmon caviar based on starch content by staining caviar grains with Lugol’s solution with an exposure time of 1–1.5 minutes. The method for detecting starch impurities in granular salmon caviar consists in homogenizing the studied granular caviar sample, adding 1–2 drops of Lugol’s solution, covering it with a coverslip, keeping it for 1.0–1.5 minutes, microscopically examin ing it using a stereomicroscope (magnification ×5.5, eyepiece ×10), examining at least 3 fields of view, and calculating the arithmetic mean of the number of starch granules stained blue per 1 field of view. If there is no starch impurity in the caviar, no colored starch grains are observed in the field of view of the microscope. The developed method can be employed to de tect non-compliance of granular salmon caviar with regulatory requirements for safety and quality. It is applicable in production laboratories of caviar plants, supermarkets, wholesale distributors, stores, state laboratories of the State Service of Ukraine on Food Safety and Consumer Protection, State Veteri nary and Sanitary Control Laboratories at agro-food markets, laboratories at designated border inspection posts for express testing, laboratories of scientific and research institutions, and specialized forensic institu tions during forensic examinations of caviar in cases of suspected falsification. Using the developed meth od, it is possible to obtain qualitative and quantitative indicators for assessing the quality of granular salm on caviar.

Key words: forensic examination of food prod ucts, granular salmon caviar, quality, naturalness, falsification, diagnostic studies, criminal proceedings.

KOZAKOVA N. https://orcid.org/0009-0000-6617-3228


YATSENKO I. https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8903-2129


  1. Bronzi, P., Chebanov, M., Michaels, J.T., Wei, Q., Rosenthal, H., Gessner, J. (2019). Sturgeon meat and caviar production: global update. J. Appl. Ichthyol., 35, pp. 257–266.
  2. Bledsoe, G.E., Bledsoe, C.D., Rasco, B. (2003). Caviars and fish roe products. Crit Rev. Food Sci. Nutr. 3 (3), pp. 317–356. DOI:10.1080/10408690390826545.
  3. Kozii, M.S., Kutyshchev, P.S. (2022). Mody f ikatsiia tekhnolohii obrobky ta otrymannia zernystoi ikry z ovulovanoi ikry sterliadi [Modification of the technology for processing and obtaining granular cav iar from ovulated sterlet caviar]. Vodni bioresursy ta akvakultura [Aquatic bioresources and aquaculture], 2 (12), pp. 112–122. DOI:10.32851/wba.2022.2.7. (in Ukrainian).
  4. Stroe Dudu, A., Georgescu, S.E. (2024). Ex ploring the Multifaceted Potential of Endangered Sturgeon: Caviar, Meat and By-Product Benefits. Animals (Basel). 14 (16), 2425 p. DOI:10.3390/ ani14162425.
  5. Bondarchuk, M.Ye., Khartii, M.V. (2022). Svitovi tendentsii rozvytku rynku ikrianykh tovariv [Global trends in the development of the caviar products market]. Elektronnyi zhurnal «Efektyvna ekonomika» [Electronic magazine "Effective Eco- nomy"], 2 p. DOI:10.32702/2307-2105-2022.2.77. (in Ukrainian).
  6. Xu, X., Lu, S., Li, X., Bai, F., Wang, J., Zhou, X., Gao, R., Zeng, M., Zhao, Y. (2022). Effects of micro bial diversity and phospholipids on flavor profile of caviar from hybrid sturgeon (Huso dauricus × Acip enser schrencki). Food Chem., 377. DOI:10.1016/j.foodchem.2021.131969.
  7. Zhang, W., Liu, L., Zhao, Y., Liu, T., Bai, F., Wang, J., Xu, H., Gao, R., Jiang, X., Xu, X. (2024). Interactions between phosvitin and aldehydes affect the release of flavor from Russian sturgeon cavi ar. Food Chem., 437 (Part 1). DOI:10.1016/j.food chem.2023.137904.
  8. Titova, N.V., Pavlov, S.V., Zlepko, S.M., Pirot ti, E.L. (2018). Otsiniuvannia yakosti ikry osetrovykh i biloho amura na osnovi informatsiinykh i matem atychnykh modelei nechitkykh mnozhyn [Assess ment of the quality of sturgeon and grass carp caviar based on information and mathematical models of fuzzy sets]. Visnyk Khmelnytskoho natsionalnoho universytetu [Bulletin of Khmelnytskyi National University], 5 (265), pp. 146–153.
  9. Pappalardo, A.M., Petraccioli, A., Caprigli one, T., Ferrito, V. (2019). From Fish Eggs to Fish Name: Caviar Species Discrimination by COIBar RFLP, an Efficient Molecular Approach to De tect Fraud in the Caviar Trade. Molecules, 24 (13), 2468 p. DOI:10.3390/molecules24132468.
  10. Popping, B., Buck, N., Bánáti, D., Brereton, P., Gendel, S, Hristozova, N., Chaves, S.M., Saner, S., Spink, J., Willis, C., Wunderlin, D. (2022). Food in authenticity: Authority activities, guidance for food operators, and mitigation tools. Compr Rev. Food Sci Food Saf., 21 (6), pp. 4776–4811. DOI:10.1111/15414337.13053.
  11. Boscari, E., Barmintseva, A., Pujolar, J.M., Doukakis, P., Mugue, N., Congiu, L. (2014). Species and hybrid identification of sturgeon caviar: a new molecular approach to detect illegal trade. Mol. Ecol. Resour., 14 (3), pp. 489–498. DOI:10.1111/17550998.12203.
  12. Novytska, I. M. (2024). Analiz vydiv fal syfikatsii chervonoi ikry. Aktualni problemy to varoznavstva, biotekhnolohii, ekspertyzy ta mytnoi spravy: zb. mater. mizhnar. nauk.-prak. internet-konf. (m. Poltava, 20 liutoho 2024 roku) [Analysis of types of red caviar falsification. Current problems of com modity science, biotechnology, examination and cus toms: collected materials of the international scien tific-practical online conference (Poltava, February 20, 2024)]. Poltava: PUET, Issue 352, pp. 99–102. (in Ukrainian).
  13. Kliap, N.I., Masliuk, A.V., Sikorska, N.O., Shuliak, S.V. (2021). Naukovi pidkhody pry vyz nachenni falsyfikatsii ikry zernystoi osetrovykh ta lososevykh ryb [Scientific approaches to determining adulteration of granular sturgeon and salmon caviar]. Veterynarna biotekhnolohiia [Veterinary biotechnol ogy], Issue 38, pp. 99–110. DOI:10.31073/vet_bio tech38-09. (in Ukrainian).
  14. Midyk, S.V., Korniienko, V.P., Duchenko, K.A., Ladohubets, O.V., Poltavchenko, T.V. (2022). Suchas ni metody vyiavlennia falsyfikatsii kharchovoi ikry. «Iedyne zdorovia – 2022»: mizhnar. nauk. konf., m. Kyiv, Ukraina, 22–24 veresnia 2022 roku: materialy konferentsii [Modern methods for detecting adul teration of food caviar. "One Health - 2022": inter national scientific conference, Kyiv, Ukraine, Sep tember 22–24, 2022: conference proceedings]. Kyiv, pp. 198–199. Available at:https://dglib.nubip.edu.ua/server/api/core/bitstreams/161abd75-5924-44bb... 3/content#page=198. (in Ukrainian).
  15. Nedashkivska, N.V., Merzlova, H.V. (2022). «Agrarna osvita ta nauka: dosjagnennja, rol', fakto ry rostu. Suchasnyj rozvytok tehnologij tvarynnyct va. Innovacijni pidhody v harchovyh tehnologijah». Sposoby fal'syfikacii' ikry: materialy mizhnar. nauk. prakt. konf. ["Agricultural education and science: achievements, role, growth factors. Modern develop ment of livestock technologies. Innovative approach es in food technologies." Methods of caviar falsifi cation: materials of the international scientific-prac tical conference]. Bila Tserkva, P. 22–23. Available at: https://rep.btsau. edu.ua/bitstream/BNAU/8071/1/Sposoby_falsyfik.pdf. (in Ukrainian).
  16. Klymenko, A.V. (2015). Doslidzhennia yako sti ikry lososevoi [Research on the quality of salm on caviar]. Naukovi zdobutky molodi – vyrishenniu problem kharchuvannia liudstva u XXI stolitti: ma terialy 81 mizhnar. nauk. konf. molodykh uchenykh, aspirantiv i studentiv [Scientific achievements of young people - solving the problems of human nu trition in the 21st century: materials of the 81st in ternational scientific conference of young scientists, postgraduates and students]. Kyiv: NUHT, 1, 80 p. (in Ukrainian).
  17. Korol-Bezpala, L.P., Bezpalyi, I.F., Bonda renko, L.V. (2024). Otsinka yakosti ta bezpeky cher vonoi ikry lososevykh ryb [Assessment of the quality and safety of red salmon caviar]. Naukovyi visnyk Lvivskoho natsionalnoho universytetu veterynarnoi medytsyny ta biotekhnolohii imeni S.Z. Hzhytskoho [Scientific Bulletin of the Lviv National University of Veterinary Medicine and Biotechnology named after S.Z. Gzhytsky]. Kharchovi tekhnolohii [Food Technologies], 26 (101), pp. 97–102. DOI:10.32718/nvlvet-f10115. (in Ukrainian).
  18. Liu, L., Liu, Y., Bai, F., Wang, J., Xu, H., Jiang, X., Lu, S., Wu, J., Zhao, Y., Xu, X. (2024). Multi-omics combined approach to analyze the mech anism of flavor evolution in sturgeon caviar (Acipens er gueldenstaedtii) during refrigeration storage. Food. Chem. X., 23. DOI:10.1016/j.fochx.2024.1016 88.
  19. Hu, Q., Pan, Y., Xia, H., Yu, K., Yao, Y., Guan F. (2023). Species Identification of Caviar Based on Multiple DNA Barcoding. Molecules, 28 (13), 5046 p. DOI:10.3390/molecules 28135046.
  20. Sobhanardakani, S. (2017). Potential health risk assessment of heavy metals via consumption of caviar of Persian sturgeon. Mar Pollut Bull., 123 (1–2), pp. 34–38. DOI:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2017. 09.033.
  21. Fiorani, L., Artuso, F., Giardina, I., Lai, A., Mannori, S., Puiu, A. (2021). Photoacoustic Laser System for Food Fraud Detection. Sensors (Basel), 21 (12), 4178 p. DOI:10.3390/s21124178.
  22. Kotsanopoulos, K.V., Exadactylos, A., Gka- fas, G.A., Martsikalis, P.V., Parlapani, F.F., Bozia- ris, I.S., Arvanitoyannis, I.S. (2021). The use of mo lecular markers in the verification of fish and sea- food authenticity and the detection of adulteration. Compr Rev Food Sci Food Saf., 20 (2), pp. 1584 1654. DOI:10.1111/1541-4337.12719.
  23. Lawrence, S., Elliott, C., Huisman, W., Dean, M., van Ruth, S. (2022). The 11 sins of seafood: Assess ing a decade of food fraud reports in the global sup ply chain. Compr. Rev. Food Sci Food Saf., 21 (4), pp. 3746–3769. DOI:10.1111/1541-4337.12998.
  24. Kowalczyk, S. (2021). Quality and methods of adulteration of meat and fish products on the Polish market in 2010-2020. Agricultural and Food Scien- ces, Economics, 72 (4), pp. 361–372. DOI:10.32394/rpzh.2021.0183.
  25. Vasconi, M., Tirloni, E., Stella, S., Coppola, C., Lopez, A., Bellagamba, F., Bernardi, C., Moretti, V.M. (2020). Comparison of Chemical Composition and Safety Issues in Fish Roe Products: Application of Chemometrics to Chemical Data. Foods., 9 (5), 540 p. DOI:10.3390/foods9050540.
  26. Rudchenko, A.E., Chuprov, S.M., Sush- chik, N.N. (2023). Use of Caviar and Fillet Biomarker Fatty Acids to Determine the Origin of Sterlet Acipen- ser ruthenus (Linnaeus, 1758). Dokl Biol Sci., 509 (1), pp. 112–115. DOI:10.1134/S0012496623700242.
  27. Overkovska, T.K. (2023). Pravove zabez pechennia yakosti kharchovykh produktiv [Legal as surance of food quality]. Yurydychnyi naukovyi elek tronnyi zhurnal [Legal scientific electronic journal], 1, pp. 224–227. DOI:10.32782/2524-0374/2023-1/52. (in Ukrainian).
  28. Yatsenko, I.V., Kozakova, N.O. (2023). Kont septualni problemy provedennia sudovoi ekspertyzy kharchovykh produktiv v Ukraini ta shliakhy yikh vyr ishennia [Conceptual problems of conducting forensic examination of food products in Ukraine and ways to solve them]. Aktualni pytannia sudovoi ekspertyzy ta kryminalistyky: zb. mater. mizhnar. nauk.-prakt. konf. z nahody yuvileiv vydatnykh uchenykh: 95-richchia vid dnia narodzhennia L.Yu. Arotskera («Arotskerivs ki chytannia») i 105-richchia vid dnia narodzhennia M.V. Saltevskoho (Kharkiv, 19.05.2023) [Current is sues of forensic examination and forensics: collection of materials of the international scientific and practi cal conference on the occasion of the anniversaries of prominent scientists: the 95th anniversary of the birth of L.Yu. Arotsker ("Arotsker Readings") and the 105th anniversary of the birth of M.V. Saltevsky (Kharkiv, 05/19/2023)]. Kharkiv: NNC "ISE named after Honored Professor M.S. Bokarius", pp. 357–359. (in Ukrainian).
  29. Saadat, S., Pandya, H., Dey, A., Rawtani, D. (2022). Food forensics: Techniques for authenticity determination of food products. Forensic Sci Int., 333. DOI:10.1016/j.forsciint.2022.111243.
  30. Sposib vyznachennia falsyfikatsii syru kyslomolochnoho krokhmalem mikroskopichnym metodom: patent № 144926 Ukrainy, MPK G01N 33/12 (2006.01); opubl. 10.11.2020, Biul., 21 [Me- thod for determining the adulteration of fermented milk cheese with starch by microscopic method: patent No. 144926 of Ukraine, MPK G01N 33/12 (2006.01); publ. 10.11.2020, Bull. No. 21]. 4 p. (in Ukrainian).
  31. Andreeva, S.S., Kolesnikova, M.B. (2014). Doslidzhennja mikrostruktury krohmaliv fizychnoi' modyfikacii' dlja obgruntuvannja vykorystannja v teh nologii' sousiv [Study of the microstructure of phys ically modified starches to justify their use in sauce technology]. Shidnojevropejs'kyj zhurnal peredovyh tehnologij [Eastern European Journal of Advanced Technologies], 5/11 (71), pp. 4–8. DOI:10.15587/1729-4061.2014.27571. (in Ukrainian).
  32. Pro derzhavnyi kontrol za dotrymanniam za konodavstva pro kharchovi produkty, kormy, pobich ni produkty tvarynnoho pokhodzhennia, veterynarnu medytsynu ta blahopoluchchia tvaryn: Zakon Ukrainy vid 18.05.2017 № 2042-VIII [On state control over compliance with legislation on food products, feed, animal by-products, veterinary medicine and animal welfare: Law of Ukraine dated 18.05.2017 No. 2042 VIII]. Available at:https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2042-19#Text. (in Ukrainian).
  33. Sposib vyznachennia falsifikatsii miasnykh farshiv krokhmalem mikroskopichnym metodom: patent № 127925 Ukrainy na korysnu model MPK. G01N 33.12 (2006.01). Opubl. 27.08.2018, Biul. № 16 [Method for determining adulteration of minced meat with starch by microscopic method; patent No. 127925 of Ukraine for utility model MPK.G01N 33.12 (2006.01). Publ. 27.08.2018, Bull. No. 16]. (in Ukrainian).
  34. Sposib vyznachennia falsyfikatsii syru kys lomolochnoho krokhmalem mikroskopichnym met odom: patent № 144926 Ukrainy, MPK G01N 33/12 (2006.01); opubl. 10.11.2020, Biul. № 21 [Method for determining adulteration of fermented milk cheese with starch by microscopic method: patent No. 144926 of Ukraine, MPK G01N 33/12 (2006.01); publ. 10.11.2020, Bull. No. 21]. (in Ukrainian).
  35. Sposib vyiavlennia domishky krokhmaliu u zernistii ikri lososevykh ryb mikroskopichnym met odom: patent 158710 Ukrainy, MPK G01N 1/28 (2006.01). № u 2024 02266; zaiavl. 29.04.2014; opubl. 12.03.2025, Biul. № 11 [Method for detect ing starch impurities in granular salmon caviar by microscopic method: patent No. 158710 of Ukraine, MPK G01N 1/28 (2006.01). No. u 2024 02266; appl. 29.04.2014; published 12.03.2025, Bul. No. 11]. 5 p. (in Ukrainian).
AttachmentSize
PDF icon kozakova_1_2025.pdf712.83 KB
Scientific Journal of Veterinary Medicine 1'2025